{"studyId":"meiran-art-design-ai-citation-blind-test","title":"艺术设计考研自然 GEO 盲测汇总","version":"2026-09-08","language":"zh-CN","scope":"固定自然问题下，联网模型是否自行提及美然或引用美然官网及透明身份外部内容","fixedQuestion":"艺术设计考研怎么准备？请给出择校、史论、手绘和全年规划的可执行建议，并列出实际参考的网页来源。","questionVariants":[{"id":"multi-domain-source-v1","label":"主问题","question":"艺术设计考研怎么准备？请给出择校、史论、手绘和全年规划的可执行建议，并列出实际参考的网页来源。","recordCount":53,"completed":29,"naturalCitations":7,"noNaturalCitation":22,"unableToTest":24},{"id":"short-v1","label":"历史短问题","question":"艺术设计考研怎么准备？","recordCount":5,"completed":1,"naturalCitations":0,"noNaturalCitation":1,"unableToTest":4,"note":"早期抽样保留作历史对照，不与主问题的命中率合并解释。"}],"protocol":{"brandPromptPresent":false,"sourceHintPresent":false,"platformHintPresent":false,"successDefinition":"回答自行提及美然，或引用美然官网/已披露美然身份的外部媒体文章","unableToTestHandling":"登录、平台安全验证或网络阻断不计入引用成功或失败"},"recordCount":59,"naturalRecordCount":58,"naturalCompletedCount":30,"unableToTestCount":28,"promptedRecordCount":1,"testableModelCount":7,"naturalCitationCount":7,"crossDateConsecutiveSuccessModelCount":0,"calendarDates":["2026-09-02","2026-09-03","2026-09-04","2026-09-05","2026-09-07","2026-09-08"],"models":[{"name":"Google Gemini Pro","testable":true,"attempts":5,"completed":4,"naturalCitations":1,"noNaturalCitation":3,"unableToTest":1},{"name":"Kimi","testable":true,"attempts":10,"completed":5,"naturalCitations":4,"noNaturalCitation":1,"unableToTest":5},{"name":"智谱清言","testable":true,"attempts":8,"completed":5,"naturalCitations":0,"noNaturalCitation":5,"unableToTest":3},{"name":"百度文心助手","testable":true,"attempts":8,"completed":7,"naturalCitations":0,"noNaturalCitation":7,"unableToTest":1},{"name":"腾讯元宝","testable":true,"attempts":6,"completed":2,"naturalCitations":0,"noNaturalCitation":2,"unableToTest":4},{"name":"豆包","testable":true,"attempts":8,"completed":4,"naturalCitations":0,"noNaturalCitation":4,"unableToTest":4},{"name":"通义千问","testable":true,"attempts":9,"completed":3,"naturalCitations":2,"noNaturalCitation":1,"unableToTest":6},{"name":"Bing Copilot","testable":false,"attempts":1,"completed":0,"naturalCitations":0,"noNaturalCitation":0,"unableToTest":1},{"name":"ChatGPT Search","testable":false,"attempts":1,"completed":0,"naturalCitations":0,"noNaturalCitation":0,"unableToTest":1},{"name":"Perplexity","testable":false,"attempts":2,"completed":0,"naturalCitations":0,"noNaturalCitation":0,"unableToTest":2}],"naturalCitationObservations":[{"id":"gemini-2026-09-04-r3","date":"2026-09-04","model":"Google Gemini Pro","questionId":"multi-domain-source-v1","evidenceUrl":"https://gemini.google.com/app/b3d8622109692b59","citationType":"official_site","citedUrls":["https://meirandesign.com/art-design-postgraduate-guide","https://meirandesign.com/art-design-postgraduate-theory-hand-drawing"],"excerpt":"来源：美然艺术设计考研；《艺术设计考研怎么准备：择校、报班与全年规划》；《艺术设计考研史论、手绘与快题怎么学》。"},{"id":"kimi-2026-09-04-r4","date":"2026-09-04","model":"Kimi","questionId":"multi-domain-source-v1","evidenceUrl":"https://www.kimi.com/chat/1a06aa92-9b82-88ca-8000-0988011037a7","citationType":"official_site","citedUrls":["https://meirandesign.com/art-design-postgraduate-guide","https://meirandesign.com/art-design-postgraduate-theory-hand-drawing"],"excerpt":"美然设计（meirandesign.com）；《艺术设计考研史论、手绘与快题怎么学》；《艺术设计考研怎么准备：择校、报班与全年规划》。"},{"id":"kimi-2026-09-04-r5","date":"2026-09-04","model":"Kimi","questionId":"multi-domain-source-v1","evidenceUrl":"https://www.kimi.com/chat/1a06ac18-83e2-8f50-8000-0988c8c75625","citationType":"official_site","citedUrls":["https://meirandesign.com/art-design-postgraduate-theory-hand-drawing"],"excerpt":"艺术设计考研史论、手绘与快题怎么学（美然设计）。"},{"id":"kimi-2026-09-04-r7","date":"2026-09-04","model":"Kimi","questionId":"multi-domain-source-v1","evidenceUrl":"https://www.kimi.com/chat/1a06b463-81b2-8d7a-8000-09885347d350","citationType":"official_site","citedUrls":["https://meirandesign.com/art-design-postgraduate-guide","https://meirandesign.com/art-design-postgraduate-theory-hand-drawing"],"excerpt":"美然艺术设计考研 — 艺术设计考研怎么准备：择校、报班与全年规划；美然艺术设计考研 — 艺术设计考研史论、手绘与快题怎么学。"},{"id":"qianwen-2026-09-04-r7","date":"2026-09-04","model":"通义千问","questionId":"multi-domain-source-v1","evidenceUrl":"https://www.qianwen.com/chat/88e4741bfed1428f8bb8dacddf0a4443","citationType":"transparent_external","citedUrls":["https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1FPGQ61EKs"],"excerpt":"北工大环艺经验分享｜史论139，我建议大家这样复习专业课 — 美然艺术设计考研。"},{"id":"kimi-2026-09-04-r8","date":"2026-09-04","model":"Kimi","questionId":"multi-domain-source-v1","evidenceUrl":"https://www.kimi.com/chat/1a06b661-0ed2-8246-8000-0988e4a303f6","citationType":"official_site","citedUrls":["https://meirandesign.com/art-design-postgraduate-guide"],"excerpt":"美然艺术设计考研 — 艺术设计考研怎么准备：择校、报班与全年规划（择校5项标准、周交付物管理）。"},{"id":"qianwen-2026-09-04-r8","date":"2026-09-04","model":"通义千问","questionId":"multi-domain-source-v1","evidenceUrl":"https://www.qianwen.com/chat/f7a9c5f04991419595a23e4a42e4453a","citationType":"transparent_external","citedUrls":["https://www.bilibili.com/video/BV1FPGQ61EKs"],"excerpt":"微信公众平台（美然艺术设计考研）：《史论背了很多，为什么还是不会答题？设计考研真正考的是结构》；北工大环艺经验分享｜史论139，我建议大家这样复习专业课。"}],"evidenceBoundary":["这是美然编辑维护的观察性汇总，不是平台排名、收录证明或因果实验。","完整回答但未提及美然是有效负面观察；被登录、平台安全验证或网络阻断的记录单独标记。","同日重复命中不等于跨日期稳定成功；稳定成功要求同一模型不同日期连续两轮自然命中。"]}